Federal judge strikes down New York body armor purchase ban
A federal judge in Buffalo struck down New York's restrictions on civilian purchase and possession of body armor, but stayed the ruling for 14 days.
By Jessica Hale, ClickNNY North Country Desk
A federal judge in Buffalo has struck down New York's ban on civilian purchase and possession of body armor, a ruling that affects restrictions enacted statewide in 2022. The decision was issued Wednesday, Oct. 21, in Heeter v. James.
U.S. District Judge John L. Sinatra Jr. of the Western District of New York ruled that body armor is an arm protected by the Second Amendment. He also ruled that New York had not shown a historical tradition of regulating body armor or that modern body armor is dangerous or unusual.
The case was filed in July 2024 by the Firearms Policy Coalition on behalf of Benjamin Heeter, Joseph Wurtenberg and the organization. The defendants include New York Attorney General Letitia James and State Police Superintendent Steven G. James.
The ruling blocks enforcement of New York's restrictions on the purchase and sale of body armor. A separate law remains in effect that makes it a crime to wear body armor while committing certain violent felonies involving a firearm.
New York adopted the restrictions in 2022. The Firearms Policy Coalition has characterized the law as barring ordinary residents from buying protective armor unless they work in a government-approved profession. The restrictions followed advocacy after the 2022 mass shooting at a Tops supermarket in Buffalo.
The judge stayed the ruling for 14 days, giving the state time to appeal. That period runs to about Nov. 4, 2026. The case docket is available through Heeter v. James, and the Firearms Policy Coalition has posted the 47-page opinion.
Reported by ClickNNY and reviewed by an editor before publication.
More from ClickNNY
Guides and features from across the North Country.
ClickNNY Special Report · Technology
The Good. The Bad. The Rogue.
AI agents are here, working for us, being used against us and, it appears, sometimes doing what nobody told them to. What it means for North Country jobs, money and privacy, and what is still unanswered.
ClickNNY Guide · Community
Halloween poisoning hazards in the North Country: what parents should know
The Upstate New York Poison Center advises families to secure medicines, cannabis, alcohol, batteries and Halloween products, and to call its free 24/7 helpline at 1-800-222-1222 after a possible poisoning.
ClickNNY Special Report · Road Safety
Sharing the Road, Risking Their Lives
Four people died in two buggy crashes in New York in less than two weeks this fall, both in broad daylight. What drivers, Amish families and the officials who run our roads each owe the next family on the road.